LINE-X vs. Drop-In Liners


Differences

A bedliner is a tool that can enhance the productivity, durability and appearance of your truck. There are two distinct types of liners available today.

Drop-In

dropin_ill

A drop-in bedliner is a plastic cover for the surface of a truck’s bed. Drop-ins require drilled holes to be installed. Drop-ins typically trap water and debris between the liner and the bed. As a result, a drop-in bedliner actually promotes condensation, water damage, abrasion, rust and corrosion.

Spray-On

sprayon_ill

Spray-Ons bond permanently to your truck bed. Spray-Ons mold around every contour, providing a weather and water tight seal, for extreme protection. This gives your bed a factory installed look, with no lost cargo space.

Features

Line-X

Drop-Ins

Other Spray-Ons

Durable, Impact absorbing Not All Not All
Dampens sound and vibration  
No lost cargo space (molds to every contour)    
Environmentally friendly   Not All
Tough, consistent surface   Not All
Resists most chemicals   Not All
Prevents load shifts – Non-slip surface Not All
Scratch and dent resistant Not All
Provides years of reliable service Not All
Prevents rust and corrosion Not All
Allows natural drainage from the bed Not All
Available in colours Not All
Adds value to your vehicle  Not All

 

Protection

There are plenty of reasons why most truck owners are now avoiding drop-in bedliners. But in a vast majority of cases, the primary issue is protection. Protection, after all, is the bedliner’s primary job. True protection of the truck bed begins with the installation of the bedliner itself.

A drop-in bedliner requires the installer to drill holes into your trucks bed and rails which destroys the truck’s original appearance and leaves new exposed areas where rust can begin building up over time. That’s right, in order to ensure proper installation of the drop-in bedliner, the installer must first drill multiple holes into your truck bed leaving it more vulnerable to the elements in which it was created to protect.

So before buying a drop-in bedliner, ask yourself: Does it make sense to protect the truck bed by first destroying its appearance and built-in corrosion resistance?

By comparison, a spray-on bedliner, is installed simply by preparing the surface and then coating it with a protective material that will protect the truck’s bed for the lifetime of the truck. Once the bedliner is installed, you should expect it to provide maximum resistance to dents, scratches/scrapes, damage caused by trapped water, and other potential problems.

Warranty

Who pays if your bedliner fails or flies out? This is another important “protection” issue – protection of the truck owner if the bedliner fails to live up to its expectations.

Some drop-in bedliners are covered with a nationwide warranty – but they won’t cover the repair that is needed on your truck’s bed from the excessive wear and tear caused by the vibration from the liner that was there to “protect” your truck’s bed.

Leading spray-on bedliner companies offer a nationwide warranty, so you don’t have to negotiate with your original installer or pay for the repairs yourself.

Appearance

Spray-on bedliners mold to your trucks bed. One of the many reasons a spray-on bedliner looks appealing is the custom look of the sprayed finish. And one leading spray-on company (LINE-X) has developed a product that will protect the liner from UV exposure, giving the truck bed a lasting visual appeal while maintaining its protective qualities for the lifetime of the truck.

Drop-in bedliners are molded with their own unique patterns that ultimately minimize the truck’s cargo space. Truck manufacturers spend millions of dollars to engineer and design their truck’s beds for maximum cargo space and overall appearance. Why destroy their efforts when its unnecessary?

Durability

Bedliner thickness doesn’t play a big role in impact resistance anymore. Recent research has proven that the impact resistance of the thin surface of a leading spray-on bedliner (LINE-X) is actually strong enough to protect the walls of the Pentagon and many other government agencies from a terrorist bomb.

The durability and strength of spray-on bedliners has given rise to additional uses of the product. Paxcon, a division of Line-X, has been used as a anti-terrorism bomb blast protective coating.

Known in military and research circles as an Energy Resistant Coating (ERC), the LINE-X coating is flexible yet stronger than steel. Walls painted with LINE-X withstand explosions up to 20 times greater than what a normal, uncoated wall can withstand. The paint holds numerous types of structural materials together – wood, steel, dry wall, concrete, brick and more. Bombed walls flex but stay together.

A drop-in bedliner provides abrasion (scratch/scrape) resistance on its own surface, but destroys the trucks surface in the process. Drop-ins are highly susceptible to causing abrasion damage to the trucks bed. And keep in mind that when a scratch penetrates the truck’s bed, it exposes your truck’s bare sheet metal allowing for rust and corrosion to take over.

TECHNICAL COMPARISONS TO THE COMPETITION
PROPERTY TEST METHOD LINE-X RESULTS* OTHER SPRAY-ON BEDLINERS
Hardness ASTM D2240 50 85-90 Shore A
Tensile Strength ASTM D412 2147 PSI 1700-1900 PSI
Elongation ASTM D412 91% 325-375%
Tear Strength ASTM D624 295 lbs/in. 140-150 lbs/in.
*LINE-X out performs the competition in every category.

The Bottom Line

After reviewing all the facts, it appears that spray-on bedliners are by far the best investment for truck bed protection.

Before you make your final decision on what bedliner is best for you, we recommend that you take the 4 key characteristics into great consideration:

  1. Appearance
  2. Protection
  3. Durability
  4. Warranty

LINE-X vs. Spray-On Liners

How can you tell the superiority of Line-X spray-on liners compared to other spray-on liners? Use these tests to find out!

Rub It!

Take a sample of LINE-X and rub it together with any other bed liner sample…notice how our higher performance product sands away the softer competition? Tool boxes, construction material, sports equipment, etc. won’t wear away the textured LINE-X surface.

Hit It!

Hit a sample of LINE-X and hit any other bed liner sample…see how our competition splits or shatters? LINE-X takes protection to the next level…our higher tensile strength resists impact, cuts, & gouges better than all other bed liners. Safety first: wear eye and hand protection and place samples on a concrete surface and fix each in place to prevent movement.

Cut It!

When you cut a LINE-X sample with a sharp knife, notice how the cut nearly disappears. When you cut a competitors sample, it’s easier to find the cut! LINE-X stands up to the hardest use…it’s good to know your truck bed will continue to look good. Safety first: wear eye and hand protection and fix sample in place to prevent movement.

Look!

LINE-X has the refined, consistent grain surface that looks like it came from the factory. Unlimited thickness…non-skid protection that looks great! Other spray-ons have been called the “cottage cheese look” due to their rough, inconsistent appearance. Plus, because they do not dry instantly like LINE-X does, it’s difficult for them to get thick coverage on the sides because heavy spray will drip and sag.